Once I use a phrase . . . Medical analogies and analogues

Analogies and analogues

The phrases “analogy” and “analogue” come from the Greek phrase ἀναλογία, which had a number of totally different meanings, together with mathematical proportion, proportion basically, correspondence, and resemblance. The meanings that dominate English as we speak are reasoning on the idea of parallel instances (analogy) and types of expertise apart from digital (analogue).

Though “analogy” entered English within the fifteenth century, through the Latin analogia and the French analogie, with the now out of date that means of proportion or mathematical settlement of ratios, most of its different meanings didn’t emerge till the sixteenth century or barely later, together with “a factor which (or often one that) corresponds to or resembles one other; a parallel, an equal ….”1

Right here, for instance, is the Elizabethan doctor Philip Barrough in The Methode of Physicke in 1583: “Due to this fact by the instance and analogie of 1 distinction of tumours, that are triggered thorough defluxion (for right here we thoughts to intreate solely of them) we’ll perceive additionally different variations, which do develop by means of the flowing of humours.”2

The time period “analogue” took even longer to emerge, not showing till the beginning of the nineteenth century. The French naturalist Étienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (1794–1866) is remembered for his work on teratology and, by means of his idea of analogy, his contributions to evolutionary biology.34 He launched his idea in 1818: “La prévision à laquelle nous porte cette vérité, c’est-à-dire le pressentiment que nous trouverons toujours, dans chaque famille, tous les matériaux organiques que nous aurons aperçus dans une autre, est ce que j’ai embrassé dans le cours de mon ouvrage sous la désignation de Théorie des Analogues.”5

Then in 1837 William Whewell (1772–1844), the inventor of a number of scientific phrases, together with scientist, physicist, and linguistics, reported Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire’s idea6: “The disciples of the previous of the 2 faculties categorical their tenets by the phrases unity of plan, unity of composition; and the extra detailed developement [sic] of those doctrines has been termed the Concept of Analogues, by Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire, who claims this idea as his personal creation. In keeping with this idea, the construction and features of animals are to be studied by the steering of their analogy solely; our consideration is to be turned, to not the health of the group for any finish of life or motion, however to its resemblance to different organizations by which it’s progressively derived from the unique kind.”

Essentially the most broadly acquainted use of the time period analogue as we speak might be in analogue expertise, contrasted with digital expertise, as utilized for instance to radio and tv. For instance, think about the distinction between an analogue and a digital timepiece. An analogue watch, because the OED places it,7 is “a timepiece [that] shows data utilizing shifting palms or tips about a steady, usually round scale”; in distinction, a digital one shows the time in numbers.

Visible analogue scales

A unique kind of scale, the visible analogue scale, provides one other perception into using analogy. The time period “visible analogue scale” is surprisingly to not be discovered within the OED or in every other customary dictionary that I’ve checked out. Nevertheless, it’s outlined within the medical dictionaries. As an example, the Merriam-Webster Medical Dictionary defines it as “a testing method for measuring subjective or behavioral phenomena (as ache or dietary consumption) by which a topic selects from a gradient of options (as from ‘no ache’ to ‘worst possible ache’ or from ‘on daily basis’ to ‘by no means’) organized in linear vogue.” And within the thirtieth version of Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary it’s outlined as “[a scale] that permits a affected person to point the perceived degree of depth of a symptom (e.g. of ache) by finding its place on a line representing a spread from least depth to biggest depth.”

In different phrases, a visible analogue scale converts an concept that can’t be represented in numbers or an image into a similar system that depicts it as being quasi-dimensional. The road that types the size is used as a numerical analogue of the sensation or opinion being measured, for instance, from none in any respect to the worst potential or the smallest to the best.

Visible analogue scales had been launched within the Nineteen Twenties to symbolize phenomena that could not be measured immediately. The earliest instance was used to offer rankings of staff by their superiors.8 Different varieties of graphic score scales that had been launched shortly afterwards mimicked ordinal scales,9 of which the Likert scale was an early instance.10

A colleague, a statistician, who had requested me about using the phrase analogue on this context responded to my clarification by suggesting {that a} scale will be “analogue” within the sense I had described whereas nonetheless being “discrete.” “A five-point scale is, one may say, analogue in a single sense and digital in one other.” I agreed along with his evaluation. A visible analogue scale will be fairly like an electron or a photon of sunshine—each a wave and a particle on the identical—in that it may be each analogue and digital on the identical time. In different phrases, it represents what one may whimsically discuss with as quantum statistics.

Utilizing analogies

Analogy and precedent are associated, and within the context of the regulation the latter is outlined as “a judicial determination which constitutes an authoritative instance or rule for subsequent analogous instances.”11 Thus, a barrister, advocate, or lawyer, relying on the jurisdiction, may argue that the judgement in a earlier case was related to the case in hand. The choose or jury would then should determine to what extent the earlier case was sufficiently analogous to permit an identical conclusion to be reached within the present case.

Analogies will be helpful in schooling, when a brand new idea could also be made extra acquainted by evaluating it with an idea that’s already understood.

Additionally it is usually tempting to make use of analogies in reaching conclusions about new occasions. For instance, a brand new medication with a mechanism of motion that’s the identical as present medicines could also be anticipated to supply related outcomes when it comes to each advantages and harms. Nevertheless, that’s not at all times the case. There are, for instance, many variations between the pharmacological actions of various β-adrenoceptor antagonists (β-blockers), variations that should be understood with a view to use them correctly.12 When cerivastatin was launched, it was anticipated that it might have an identical benefit-harm steadiness to that of different statins; it didn’t—the danger of rhabdomyolysis was about 10 instances increased.13

Mathematical fashions supply analogies of the techniques they symbolize. For instance, pharmacokinetic compartmental fashions are analogies of the way in which by which the physique is constructed, representing totally different tissues by compartments within the mannequin; the compartments are related by mathematical constructs that symbolize the charges at which medicines are transferred from compartment to compartment, analogous to the precise switch of the medication from the blood to a tissue or group of tissues and again once more, or to metabolism or excretion of the drug from the physique. Physiologically primarily based pharmacokinetic (PBPK) fashions represent probably the most detailed kind of such fashions, since every of the mathematical compartments in such a mannequin represents a person tissue, such because the liver, and the transfers between the blood and the tissues have in mind the anticipated blood circulate although that tissue. Modelling of this kind is beneficial in lots of areas of pharmacology, together with drug growth,14 strategies of drug supply,15 and drug use in being pregnant.16

Extra variable in predictive energy are the Markov fashions utilized in assessing the cost-effectiveness of a therapeutic intervention, usually a drugs. Right here the result’s inclined to broad variation, relying on the structural nature of the mannequin and the values of the inputs. For instance, the estimated incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) submitted by producers to the Nationwide Institute for Well being and Care Excellence (NICE) within the UK are usually significantly decrease than these submitted by impartial evaluation teams, implying higher cost-effectiveness than may very well be the case.17

However irrespective of how good or unhealthy an analogy or an analogical mannequin is, it might solely set up the chance of a conclusion.18